The beer ferments from Dingcun in China 6,500 years ago.

 

The use of beer ferments during the Neolithic period is the subject of exciting researches in China. This technology is the main brewing method used today throughout Asia and in China for thousands of years. But since when exactly?

Location of Dingcun and Neolithic sites related to beer brewing in ChinaLocation of Dingcun and Neolithic sites related to beer brewing in China.

 

In 2020, a team of archaeologists proved that these beer ferments were used in Dingcun, a Neolithic site of the Yangshao culture (4500-3000 BC). This is the culmination of much researches to improve the detection of traces of brewing in the Huang-He river region. They mainly target the remains of starch granules that were modified by the brewing process, of phytolites, of calcium oxalate and now the remnants of microorganisms (fungi, yeasts, bacteria) involved in the saccharification of starch and the alcoholic fermentation[1].

Beer ferments ? What are we talking about? Some fungi and moulds (Rhizopus, Aspergillus, Mucor, Monascus, etc.) release enzymes that convert starch into sugars. A godsend for brewing beer, because the brewing process always starts with this compulsory operation without which no alcoholic fermentation of the starch could take place. Unlike the sweet juice of fruit, starch does not ferment spontaneously. We grow these precious microscopic fungi on cooked grain patties, let them multiply in a hot, humid, aerated container, then dry these same patties. These are what we name beer ferments. They are a concentrate of amylolytic mushrooms inside a dried cake that can be kept for months. When it's time to brew the beer, one or more dried cakes (or beer ferment) are simply well mixed with a full batch of cooked starch from any origin (grains, tubers, seeds). The brewer let the mushrooms do all the work. They will simultaneously make the sugars from the cooked starch and convert them into ethanol during one and single biochemical process. When time comes to enjoy the beer, water is added to the fermented mash in order to dilute it and get an alcoholic beverage, either filtered or not.

Westerners, who are used to thinking beer = malt, always wonder how such a brewing method can work. It has been used in Asia for at least 6,500 years!

This dating is one of the outstanding results achieved by Li Liu's team.

On the Dingcun site, 10 km from Yangshao, 9 shards from the Miaodigou phase (4000-3500 BC) were collected. The analysis was carried out on 149 starch granules, 540 phytoliths and 180 organs of microscopic fungi.

The identified plants are similar to those of Mijiaya, except that barley, yam and lilies are absent: broomcorn millet(Panicum miliaceum), foxtail millet (Setaria italica), Job's Tears (Coix lacryma-jobi), and Snake-gourd (Trichosanthes kirilowii). Rice (Oryza sp.) has also been found (Liu et al., 2014). Finally, grasses such as Agropyron, Elymus, and Leymus from northern China (Wu et al., 2006). Neither barley nor wheat.

 

Yangshao-Culture Dingcun sherds with molds and starch Li Liu 2020 Yangshao-Culture. Dingcun identified molds and fungi. Li Liu 2020
8 shards from the Dingcun site (Dahecun) analysed in 2020 by Li Liu's team, and the reference bottom pointed jar. Dingcun samples 1,2: yeast cells in budding process; 3: a cluster of yeasts; 4: spore (1–4 compared with 10); 5: sporangia with sporangiophore (compared with 8, Mucor sp.); 6: branched sporangiophore with sporangia (compared with 9, Aspergillus oryzae); 7: sporangiophore with sporangia, unidentified. Modern reference 8: Mucor sp.; 9: A. oryzae; 10: S. cerevisiae yeast cells in budding process (oval) and Aspergillus spores (round) (scale, 1–4,10: 10 µm; 5–9: 50 µm)..

 

Among the 180 fragments of fungal organs, the following were counted: yeasts (49), hyphae (86), mycelia (6), sporangia (3), sporangia with sporangiophores (14) and spores (8). The yeasts are morphologically close to the strains of wild Saccharomyces cerevisiae identified in northern China and occurring nowadays in millet beer brews. The identification of the mold species provides a clue to the ancient beer brewing methods: Mucor sp and Aspergillus oryzae. The presence of these microorganisms on shards of pottery used for brewing beer and their association with yeasts leaves little doubt. Their presence is not accidental. Aspergillus are nowadays cultivated on beer ferments in China, Korea, Japan and many Asian countries to brew many different kinds of traditional beers.

 

This is the first time that these microorganisms associated with beer fermentation technology have been identified for such a remote era and in a region that is one of the world's major brewing areas. Very ancient traces of yeasts such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae have already been found in the world. But these yeasts are involved in the alcoholic fermentation of every sugars. On the other hand, Mucor sp and Aspergillus oryzae are linked to a specific brewing method. Li Liu's team not only found and dated traces of an old beer, they also showed that the brewing technique using beer ferments is itself very old.

This technique coexisted in the Neolithic period of Dingcun with the malting technique. Some millet starch grains show signs of germination prior to cooking and fermentation, as in Mijiaya.

It can be argued that the two main brewing techniques, the beer-ferments and the malting, have coexisted for many millennia in northern China and probably over a much wider geographical area. This information is far-reaching:

  1. It confirms that different brewing methods can coexist for a long time in the same geographical area. In China, malting was marginalized in the 1st millennium, then almost completely disappeared before a forceful comeback on the Chinese territory with the Europeans in the 19th century[2].
  2. It shows that in the Neolithic period, the brewing of various kinds of beer was rooted in a general framework of food technology. This base is common to all fermented beverages. The latter become strictly speaking beers when the technology used makes it possible to differentiate them, which is the case at Dingcun or Mijiaya, but not at Jiahu 2000 years earlier. At Jiahu, the fermented beverages are a mixture of honey, mixed fruits and grains, i.e. mead-wine-beer indistinctly.
  3. What has happened in northern China during the 2 to 3 millennia that separate Jiahu from Dingcun? Societies became more complex, hierarchies and mechanisms of social domination appeared, food evolved (new plants, new domestications, new techniques), religious beliefs changed (ancestor worship) and became different from the agrarian rites that were perpetuated. At the very core of these general economic and social transformations, the brewery gradually becomes an activity in its own right, detached from the common base of undifferentiated fermented drinks. Brewing specialises in the transformation of starch (cereals, grasses, roots, bulbs, etc.). Between Jiahu and Dingcun, humans learned to master these biochemical transformations and, more surprisingly, they domesticated microscopic fungi able to convert starch into fermentable sugars.
  4. During the Bronze Age, which succeeded the Neolithic period around 1500 BC in Northern China, the brewing technologies were completely mastered. They guarantee the successful reproduction of each brew by a full-fledged brewer. After the technical mastery comes the stage of extreme refinement for the chinese fermented beverages which can now be called beers in the true meaning of the word. Beer becomes the drink symbol of the Shang and Zhou ruling classes. Various kinds of beer accompany all their deeds and gestures: meals, banquets, military campaigns, ancestor worship, divination, etc. The refinement of the Shang bronzes, the complex drinking services suppose millennia of learning and perfecting brewing techniques before a ruling class can make beer a symbol of political power. Bronze pots, vases, pitchers and cups have given rise to many interpretations regarding their shapes, and more seldom to analysis of their contents. Many aesthetical interpretations regarding them are still speaking of "wine", an unfortunatly lasting misconception !

 

Vase With Pointed Bottom-ShanghaiMuseum-May27-08 Yangshao_culture. Bouteille en forme d'amphore, Banpo. Musée_Guimet Yangshao culture. Cauldron fuYangshao_culture. Pottery Ding (Cooking_Vessel)_(ca. 5000 - 3000 B.C.). Treasures of Ancient China exhibit Yangshao-Culture. Dahecun. Pots jumeaux type hu. Dahecun(III)-Qinwangzhai._Henan_Provincial_Museum,_ZhengzhouYangshao-Culture. Dahecun painted pottery. Henan_Provincial_Museum,_Zhengzhou
Bottom pointed jar. Shanghai Museum. Yangshao culture. Amphora shaped bottle, Banpo. Musée Guimet. Yangshao culture. A Fu cauldron and a tripod cooking stove. Yangshao culture. Dahecun. Twin pots and painted pottery cup. Henan Provincial Museum, Zhengzhou.

 

The significance of these discoveries is of the greatest interest for the history of the brewing. Li Liu sums them up as follows:

« Our results provide convincing evidence that amphorae at the Dingcun site were part of alcohol production facilities. The Yangshao people there made fermented beverages with millet, rice, Job’s tears, wild Triticeae grass seeds, as well as snake gourd roots. They employed two techniques of fermentation, using malts and qu starter. The malts were probably made of sprouted broomcorn millet, Triticeae seeds and rice, while qu may have been formed with moldy grains together with herbs. »[3]

 

Some cereals are well suited to malting, others are not, such as rice. This difference and the growing importance of rice cultivation in China may explain the gradual dominance of beer ferments in Chinese brewing methods. This remains an open question for future research.

 >


[1] Li Liu, Yongqiang Li, Jianxing Hou, Making beer with malted cereals and qu starter in the Neolithic Yangshao culture, China, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, Volume 29, 2020. sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X19305486?via%3Dihu

[2] In fact, malting continues in northern China with the domestic brewing of millet beers. Hunjiu beer is brewed nowadays in Shaanxi with corn malt mixed with raw millet. The brewing method is hydrid in the sense that the thick mixture is left in a pot to both its conversion into sugars (malt action) and its alcoholic fermentation (yeast or other fungi). This semi-liquid phase is followed by a liquid phase when the beer is drunk by adding water to the brewing pot. Note the intervention of maize, a cereal that arrived late in China through contact with the Spaniards in South-East China. Evidence that domestic brewing methods are constantly changing around the world. Li Liua & al. , The origins of specialized pottery and diverse alcohol fermentation techniques in Early Neolithic China, 2019, pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1902668116 Supplemental data p. 10.

[3] Liu Li & al. 2020, 8. It is not clear whether paddy rice is suitable for malting. Harvesting the grains of rice often removes the germ. Rice can only germinate if all its husks and glumes are undamadged. This remark does not lessen in any way the relevance and pivotal importance of these investigations.

06/09/2018  Christian Berger